问HN:是否应该对新账户实施临时禁令?
关于人工智能和这个论坛的质量。我并不是说这是一个好的解决方案。但我们的用户体验正越来越受到影响,因为我们不得不眯着眼睛看评论,试图解析它们的语法和语义结构,以判断这个账户是否是真人。这并不是这个地方应该有的样子,我想这是我们大家都能达成的共识。
禁止新账户的做法听起来很草率,我同意这可能是个愚蠢的主意。我也相信Dang等人会考虑过这种做法以及其他方案。但这个地方的吸引力日渐下降,至少这一措施可以暂时堵住漏洞,直到有策略来解决机器人和代理能够创建账户、发送垃圾信息和恶意宣传这个曾经伟大的网站的问题。
为什么对新用户的需求如此迫切?尤其是考虑到现在许多账户是无法被检测到的,这与网站的精神相悖?在这个社区已经相当庞大和活跃的情况下,暂停新账户的理由是什么?
查看原文
Something something AI and quality of this forum.<p>I'm not arguing this is a good solution. But our user experience is being increasingly disrupted by squinting at comments and trying to parse their syntactic and semantic structure to discern if this account is a person or not. That is no what this place should be, and I think that is something we all agree on.<p>A new account ban sounds rash and I agree that this could be a really dumb idea. I'm also certain dang et al will have considered it amongst other approaches. But this place is becoming less compelling by the day, and at least this measure plugs the holes until there is a strategy in place to address the issue of bots and agents being able to create accounts and spam and shill the ever-living fuck out of this once great site.<p>Why even is there an urgency for new users? Especially given that many now are guaranteed to be undetectable, which that go against the ethos of the site? What is the argument against pausing new accounts, when this community is already fairly large and active?