告诉HN:Claude声称AGPLv3许可证违反了其内容政策。
在三个不同的项目中,Claude 拒绝为我的项目添加 AGPLv3 许可证,告诉我这违反了内容政策。最近一次拒绝的反馈是:<p><pre><code> API 错误:输出被内容过滤政策阻止
</code></pre>
我已经重复了这个过程四次。此外,这个问题已经被报告了相当长一段时间[1][2],包括我大约一个月前的报告(虽然我找不到链接),显然这不仅仅是我一个人遇到的情况。<p>在我看来,这是不可接受的,开始让我感觉这可能是他们的故意决定。至少对我来说,我将开始多样化(或完全转向 Codex),因为我可以预见到有一天 Claude 会开始拒绝处理 AGPL 代码库。毫无疑问,这不是 Anthropic 第一次因缺乏透明度而让我们失望。尤其让我感到困扰的是,如果他们一开始没有在 AGPL 代码上进行训练,我会感到非常惊讶。<p>说我感到失望是轻描淡写。我确实希望这一情况能够改变。<p>[1]: https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/issues/12705<p>[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46569652
查看原文
On three separate projects, Claude has refused to add an AGPLv3 license to my project, telling me that it violates the content policy. Most recent reject gave:<p><pre><code> API Error: Output blocked by content filtering policy
</code></pre>
I've reproduced this a total of four times. It has also been reported for quite some time[1][2], including by myself a month or so ago (though I can't find the link), and it is clearly not just happening to me.<p>This is unacceptable IMHO, and is beginning to feel like an intentional decision on their part. For myself at least, I'm going to start diversifying (or switching entirely to Codex) as I could see a day when Claude starts refusing to work on an AGPL codebase. It certainly wouldn't be the first time Anthropic has rug-pulled us with their lack of transparency. This is especially bothersome to me since I would be highly surprised if they didn't train on AGPL code in the first place.<p>To say I am disappointed would be an understatement. I certainly do hope this gets changed.<p>[1]: https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/issues/12705<p>[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46569652