HackerNews中文版

我注意到这个令人不安的趋势已经有一段时间了。所谓高评分（karma）是指超过1000的评分。其中一些评论奇怪得让我无法找到任何合理的解释。也许他们只是跳过了每个单词，或者以某种方式……然后回应一个想象中的评论者。不客气地说，他们可能是在随意敲击键盘、精神错乱的发泄、情绪化的发脾气等等。或者是由大型语言模型（LLM）生成的……但风格并不匹配。当然，这种现象在低评分用户中一直存在，但现在越来越多地出现在高评分用户中。举个例子，我最近遇到了一次奇怪的情况。我仔细检查了谷歌搜索结果的前10页，关于我在评论链中提到的一个声明，指出这似乎支持该声明。也许是因为有人这样做而不是随意发表意见，触发了某种反应。实际上，这并没有花费我超过5分钟的时间，但仍然……这是一到五分钟的真实努力。不久后，收到了一条奇怪的回复，指责我“没有努力”等等。这在一条高努力的回复中可能是合理的……但这实际上是一条匆忙写成的短回复……显然花费了不到一分钟的真实努力。指责我“没有努力”，要求我付出比他们更多的努力，而他们自己却“没有努力”……这造成了一条明显无意义的回复。在我指出，如果他们也“没有努力”，那么根据定义，我的努力已经超过或等于他们的努力……但没有人对此作出回应。当然，我的评论被标记了，而他们的评论却被点赞了……有没有其他人遇到过类似的情况，或者思考过这个问题的上升趋势？

查看原文

I’ve been noticing this disturbing trend for quite a while. By high karma I mean well over 1000 karma.And some of these leave comments so bizarre, that I can’t find any charitable explanation.Other than perhaps they may be skipping reading every other word or something… and then respond to an imaginary version of the parent.Uncharitably, they could be semi-random keyboard bashing, deranged bashing, emotional tantrums, and so on. Or LLM written… except the style doesnt match.Of course this has always been somewhat prevalent for low karma users, but it’s now creeping up higher and higher.For example, I had a recent bizarre encounter.I had double checked the first 10 pages of google results, in regards to a claim that I implied prior in the comment chain, mentioning that it seemed supportive of the claim.Maybe the novelty of someone doing that, and not just randomly opining, triggered something.Realistically, it didn’t take more than 5 minutes of effort, but still… it would have been 1 to 5 minutes of genuine effort.A bit later, a bizarre reply came making the accusation that I had put in “no effort”, and so on.Which might have made sense in a high effort reply… except it was a hastily written short reply… that obviously took under a minute of genuine effort.Accusing me of “no effort”, asking me to put in more effort than them, and then themselves putting in “no effort”… created a frankly nonsensical reply.After pointing it out, that if they spent “no effort” too, I would have already put in more, or equal, effort by definition… there was no response from anyone.Of course my comments were flagged and theirs was upvoted…Has anyone else encountered similar or thought about this issue spreading upwards?

为什么在HN上越来越多明显失去理智的高信誉用户出现？