问HN:我需要产品方面的帮助
我有一款高质量的SaaS产品,已经准备好上线。所有工作都已完成:产品、测试、有限责任公司、银行账户、Stripe、技术栈等。但我作为程序员,构建这个产品时只想着创造一个我一直想做的酷东西。
我的问题是,使用Claude作为法律顾问让我感到害怕。我认为的道德和法律上看似合规的事情是两回事。
为了提供一些背景,这个产品使用AI管道将用户提供的内容转换为戏剧化格式。可以把它看作是电子书到图形音频的改编(尽管还有其他管道)。质量非常出色,但让用户提供他们拥有的受版权保护的内容进行改编在法律上并不明确。ElevenLabs不添加音效,所以他们没问题,但这涉及到转录和额外的步骤。Claude的法律回应也让我感到害怕。即使采取积极的内容审核措施来拒绝与儿童性虐待材料(CSAM)相关的内容,向当局报告,封锁用户,并在服务条款中包含相关条款,仍然存在一些内容可能会漏网之鱼,从而导致我面临巨额赔偿的风险。
我还需要澄清一下,我是否被允许缓存和重用生成的资产。例如,如果生成了一句“披萨很好”,我能否在第二次以更低的成本重用它,而不是重新生成?
我只是一个没有无限资金来授权内容的独立程序员。公共领域和创作共享(CC)作品无法吸引我所需的用户兴趣。
我需要真正的法律建议,但我无法 justify 花费5000美元请律师,仅仅是为了听到这是个坏主意。我该怎么办?
查看原文
I have a very high-quality SaaS product that's ready to launch. Everything is complete: the product, testing, LLC, bank account, Stripe, tech stack, etc. But I built it as a programmer trying to create the coolest thing possible for a product I've always wanted to make.
My issue is that using Claude as a lawyer is scaring me. What I consider moral and what seems to be legal are two different things.
For context, the product uses an AI pipeline to adapt user-provided content into dramatized formats. Think of it as ebook-to-graphic-audio adaptation (though there are other pipelines). The quality is insanely good, but having users bring copyrighted content they own to be adapted is legally unclear. ElevenLabs doesn't add sound effects, so they're fine, but this involves transcription plus additional steps. Claude's legal responses are also scaring me. Even with aggressive content moderation to reject CSAM-related materials, report to authorities, block users, and include it in the ToS, there's a risk that some things could slip through and I'd get sued for massive damages.
I also need clarification on whether I'm allowed to cache and reuse generated assets. For example, if a sentence like "Pizza is good" is generated once, can I reuse it a second time at a lower cost instead of regenerating it?
I'm just a single programmer without infinite capital to license content. Public domain and CC work won't drive the user interest I need.
I need real legal advice, but I can't justify spending $5k on a lawyer just to hear this is a bad idea. What can I do?