问HN:开发者们——你们允许代理编写生产代码吗?
我认识两个优秀的开发者,我们称他们为鲍勃和比尔。
鲍勃不再写代码,他负责协调代理。他说这样能让他更高效,且产生的错误率与人类相当。他对此深信不疑。
比尔则只使用代理来编写测试和进行代码审查。他说即使是Fable 5.1也会产生1000行的错误,而他只需要10行的修复代码。他对此深信不疑。
鲍勃和比尔都是值得信赖的开发者,拥有丰富的实际开发经验,包括在谷歌的经历。
代理仍然会产生错误吗?
所谓的10倍工程师真的存在吗?
你的看法是什么?
查看原文
I know 2 good developers, let's call them Bob and Bill.<p>Bob does not write code anymore, he orchestrates agents. Says it makes him faster. That the level of slop is the same as with humans. He swears by it.<p>Bill only uses agents to write tests and do code review. He says even a Fable 5.1 will create 1,000 line slop instead of his 10 line fix. He swears by it.<p>Both Bob & Bill are both credible developers that have lots of experience at building real things, including at Google.<p>Do agents still produce slop?
Does the 10x engineer really exist?
What is your position?